Give crafters the ability to set name/description of crafted items

Satyrsfaction

@arcanigans

100% support this - I think tools like this in the hands of the player ultimately add more than they could detract.

Sure, one in twenty might make some joke dumb item that gets them a stern look from a DM, but so many more will just add to a great amount of roleplay and fun - players should be trusted to not be stupid, and help make fantastic stories through tools like these

+1

A Former User

As much as some people seem to dislike anything crafting-related, I think this is such a cool idea! If there are concerns about abuse, maybe tie this to some kind of special tool that could be earned in game / applied for?

Prettysmitten

While I do think this would be cool to implement, I suppose it would depend on how hard it is to code on whether the DM team wants to actually deal with it or not. Unless some generous person wants to volunteer to do it.

Satyrsfaction

@prettysmitten

I know of several servers that use a writing tool (I believe Arabel used to as well!) that allowed for the changing of descriptions and names. Arabel used it only for books but I believe with some amount of effort the same thing could be used for any item (though obviously would require trust in the players who got the tools as SilverSquirrel says).

Sparr0w

You're able to rename containers and blood vials using your player tool already too. So the features exist, just not for crafted items.

I do agree it would add more to RP than it would take away; I think the less players need to rely on DM loot for neat legacy items, the happier everyone will be.

Also, Echo has put a tonnnn of work into the crafting system. Why not push it to make it even more awesome?

Echo

@arcanigans deja vu? https://nodebb.cityofarabel.com/topic/55109/allow-the-changing-description-of-crafted-items

Yes it can be nice, but unfortunately, it can be really abused. Not just talking about improper names for items (Johnny's Vorpal Sword +5). Players could name items after faction items or even after plot items which could/would cause all sorts of issues in game. Also, it's probably gonna be more annoying for DMs when looking over the gear of players (yes, we do that). We'd hover over the armor, for example, and see some name we don't recognize (holy armor of the champion, or whatever) and then inspect it only to discover it's just plain iron armor.

As I said when you suggested this previously, I may look at adding a "crafted by" line in crafted gear, but keep in mind there are nearly ~~1500~~ 1000 (i took out an estimate of alchemy stuff) recipes that will need to be edited if we do this. It is a very low priority for me at the moment.

Paramour

Rules regarding the new ability to change item name/descriptions:

Item must contain the material in the name. (Example: Iron Sword of Spice, Frederick's Copper Blade). This is so that DMs can glance over the item name without having to go into the description to see what it does every time.

Items cannot be made with colored names. Only plot items henceforth will have colored names. You are not allowed to rename plot items.

Descriptions must be kept to less than three paragraphs.

Descriptions of items must not contradict their actual appearances or use.

You are not allowed to rename items to read as faction gear.

Satyrsfaction

I think making it a tool for trusted players is a far easier workaround than adding a line of code to 1000+ items. The more trust players are afforded, the better, I think - we've been playing this game a very long time, I feel as if even if it isn't a rolled out thing everyone can access, if someone shows the same care and trust to be given it, they should have it same as any other EiG or Application based shenanigans.

The rules above seem good !!

A Former User

Yes, that is how I feel about it, too. It can be abused but some trust could be extended to players who really earn this.

@satyrsfaction

Puffy

Crafters name has been added to crafters items as a start