Hangman/Orville Carrow/Wererat

Puffy

Admitting to being a lycan from the get go would mean the pc should be killed on the first day. I don't think the misfortune idea works that well on a lycan if it's meant to be inherited and as Prof said lycans are inflicted.

I'm not interested in the possibility of people going soft on a lycan, and this invites it cause no one wants to FD a player on day one and it won't be a fun story for anyone either in such a situation.

Half-orc, cansin or tiefling would fit better if he wants to go with heritage misfortunes. Then his pc isn't going to get murdered day one either.

Echo

@Puffy said in Hangman/Orville Carrow/Wererat:

Half-orc, cansin or tiefling would fit better if he wants to go with heritage misfortunes. Then his pc isn't going to get murdered day one either.

good point
cansin especially would fit better than lycan

plus i'm kinda worried about limited playing time, since he stepped down as a storyteller due to arrival of new baby

Puffy

@Echo said in Hangman/Orville Carrow/Wererat:

plus i'm kinda worried about limited playing time, since he stepped down as a storyteller due to arrival of new baby

Yeah, a conflict heavy concept with a lot of pvp isn't very fair if availability is an issue

Puffy

Puffy — Today at 15:01
Hey, so the team is discussing the app. Some of the concerns that have come up so far are:

Lycans are afflicted, so wererat doesn't quite make sense with the heresy. Something like Cansin would make more sense with the heritage angle and the gambling
Since your availability is limited, and the concept is very conflict oriented. There is the question if it would be a good idea to have such a pvp and conflict heavy concept.

Hangman — Today at 15:42
Spoke with Prof about the afflicted. I'm fine with "he got infected, which is just typical, bad luck after bad luck."
I'll look to manage any conflict to coincide with availability. I'm happy slow-burning it and building the Cult / Religion.
Its much easier to find pockets of time when it doesn't need set-up and other people's availability.

Puffy

Voting no:

Conflict heavy, not a good idea to have an conflict heavy app PC when you know your availability is poor
Lycan doesnt match the character idea very well, and again is conflict heavy
Open lycan is a bad idea

Puffy

No movement on this for a bit and I would generally advice against it, thoughts?

Echo

I think you can see how the subrace will play into the core concept and how I can use it to enhance it.

I really dont see it. Nothing about this says "werecat" to me.

I intend to be transparent about the affliction as literal evidence of familial curses.

Bad idea. Will be KoS to start with. Not fun for him. Not fun for others to be forced to go along with it.

I still think this sounds more like cansin than werecat.

Prof. Misclick

Agree with the comments from Echo and Puffy.

Salem

Also agree with Echo and Puffy

Lord_Acererak

before I let Hangman know, how would we feel about this app with the change to Cansin?

I really dont see much wrong with the app as it is, it would be pretty time heavy but thats up to Hangman to feel out.

I think this application applies just fine to Lycan/Cansin. I do agree with echo/puff that it fits -better- with Cansin.

Once I have yalls opinions ill respond to Hangman

Echo

it were cansin i'd vote yes

Prof. Misclick

Cansin sure. Has the player been talked to at all? I have a message from him from a few days ago but been too busy with travel and work to do anything about it.

The ECL + 1 sub races are supposed to be an easy app anyhow and this far exceeds the ask.

SpiffyMeister

Maybe give him cansin and a shapechanging tool he can use?

Puffy

@Prof-Misclick said in Hangman/Orville Carrow/Wererat:

Cansin sure. Has the player been talked to at all? I have a message from him from a few days ago but been too busy with travel and work to do anything about it.

The ECL + 1 sub races are supposed to be an easy app anyhow and this far exceeds the ask.

Yeah I spoke to him a few times, last thing ssaid:

Puffy — 15/11/2023 01:58
Not much movement on the app, and the concerns raised remain so far. Will let you know if there are any updates
Knockknock — 15/11/2023 09:15
I'm going to start tonight, can pull the app and I'll play it as a human. There's < 5 people playing the game though, the reluctance to move applications on is startling.
Puffy — 15/11/2023 09:15
People are just busy
Knockknock — 15/11/2023 09:16
:thumbsup:

Puffy

@SpiffyMeister said in Hangman/Orville Carrow/Wererat:

Maybe give him cansin and a shapechanging tool he can use?

Why would he get a shape changing tool?

SpiffyMeister

@Puffy idk i am spitballing

Prof. Misclick

@Puffy said in Hangman/Orville Carrow/Wererat:

@Prof-Misclick said in Hangman/Orville Carrow/Wererat:

Cansin sure. Has the player been talked to at all? I have a message from him from a few days ago but been too busy with travel and work to do anything about it.

The ECL + 1 sub races are supposed to be an easy app anyhow and this far exceeds the ask.

Yeah I spoke to him a few times, last thing ssaid:

Puffy — 15/11/2023 01:58
Not much movement on the app, and the concerns raised remain so far. Will let you know if there are any updates
Knockknock — 15/11/2023 09:15
I'm going to start tonight, can pull the app and I'll play it as a human. There's < 5 people playing the game though, the reluctance to move applications on is startling.
Puffy — 15/11/2023 09:15
People are just busy
Knockknock — 15/11/2023 09:16
:thumbsup:

Why not tell hm he is approved for Cansin and be done with it? Really taking a long time. (I freely admit I've been busy but let's get moving on this.

Prof. Misclick

Professor Misclick — Today at 8:44 PM
You around?
[8:47 PM]
If not, I'll just leave here. The app has not passed for lycan(were rat) but the team feels Cansin is appropriate if you want to go that route.

Already yes- Acererak

Cansin
Prof- Yes as Cansin
Echo- Yes as Cansin
Spiffy- Yes (we're not doing an item though)
Puffy - Yes as Cansin